Our reporter
A court in Colorado has ruled that five elephants currently housed at Cheyenne Mountain Zoo are not entitled to the same legal rights as humans, effectively blocking an attempt to free them from captivity. The ruling has sparked fresh debate over the treatment of animals in captivity and their legal standing.
The case was brought by the Nonhuman Rights Project (NRP), an animal rights group that filed the lawsuit on behalf of the elephants, who are originally from Africa. The NRP argued that the elephants had suffered long-term harm due to their confinement, likening their situation to imprisonment. They contended that the animals displayed signs of brain damage caused by the stresses of living in an enclosed environment, which they claimed was unnatural for such intelligent, social creatures.
The group’s legal team had hoped the court would invoke habeas corpus, a legal principle traditionally used to challenge unlawful detention, to secure the elephants’ release to an animal sanctuary where they could live in a more natural, expansive environment.
However, the court ultimately rejected the claim, stating that the primary question was whether elephants could be considered legal “persons” under the law. As elephants are not legally recognised as persons, the court ruled they did not have the standing to pursue a habeas corpus petition.
In a statement following the decision, Cheyenne Mountain Zoo expressed relief at the outcome but criticised the NRP for bringing the case in the first place. The zoo accused the group of using the legal process to raise funds, suggesting that their campaign was more about publicity than animal welfare.
The NRP, however, denounced the ruling, calling it a setback for animal rights. They argued that it was a “great injustice” and vowed to continue their fight for legal recognition of non-human animals. They likened their cause to past social justice movements, believing that one day courts would grant animals the right to freedom.
Get a premium automobile insurance coverage for your vehicle for as low as #15000 only and claim up to #3,000,000 in damages @Zenith Insurance To signup: WhatsApp/Call: +2349028313757
