Court delivers major blow to APC, affirms Gabriel Suswam as winner of Benue North-East senatorial primary

Share This Now!

The Federal High Court in Abuja has affirmed former Benue State Governor, Senator Gabriel Torwua Suswam, as the winner of the All Progressives Congress (APC) senatorial primary election for Benue North-East Senatorial District, dealing a major setback to the party and Senator Emmanuel Memga Udende in the lingering dispute over the party’s ticket.

The ruling followed a legal battle instituted by Suswam over his alleged unlawful substitution after emerging victorious in the APC senatorial primary.

In its findings, the court rejected preliminary objections raised by the APC and Senator Udende, clearing the way for the substantive issues in Suswam’s suit to be determined.

The defendants had challenged the suit on several grounds, including statute of limitation, the internal affairs of the political party and Suswam’s legal capacity to institute the action.

ALSO READ:  NPower Minister, Sadiya Farouq jets out of the country to give birth in United States

However, the court dismissed the objections, holding that Suswam instituted his action within the legally permissible period.

It also rejected the APC’s argument that the dispute concerned the internal affairs of a political party and was therefore beyond judicial intervention.

The court maintained that where a party member alleges that a political party violated its constitution, rules or electoral guidelines, the judiciary has the authority to intervene and determine the legality of the process.

On the issue of locus standi, the court equally ruled against Udende, dismissing the challenge to Suswam’s legal standing to pursue the case.

A major consideration in the proceedings was the documentary evidence establishing the conduct and outcome of the disputed primary election.

The court particularly examined Exhibits JSO 2 and INEC 1, describing them as statutory documents whose evidential value had not been displaced by credible contrary evidence.

ALSO READ:  Defence Minister orders restructuring of military operations

It observed that the APC and Udende failed to produce convincing evidence capable of contradicting the documents presented to establish Suswam’s victory.

The court also noted that the APC did not deny receiving a formal protest letter written by Suswam over his alleged unlawful substitution but failed to provide a response.

According to the court, the failure to respond to a formal communication raising specific grievances could, depending on the circumstances, amount to an admission of its contents.

The court further faulted the defendants for failing to produce a competing report capable of displacing the report submitted by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).

It held that the credibility and evidential weight of INEC’s report remained intact, making it reliable evidence upon which the court could act.

The court also expressed reservations about some documents tendered by the APC and Udende, questioning their authenticity and evidential reliability because the defendants failed to establish that they emanated from the third defendant.

ALSO READ:  No native doctor, prophet responsible for my victory- Gov Okpebholo

In another significant finding, the court observed that INEC’s evidence corroborated Suswam’s case, while neither the APC nor Udende successfully controverted his claims with credible evidence.

The court consequently answered all five questions submitted by Suswam in the affirmative, reinforcing his position in the dispute over the APC senatorial ticket.

 


Share This Now!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *