Fountain of Life Church Crisis: Costly CAC Mistakes Church Founders Must Avoid

Share This Now!

From Confidence Aribibia

The leadership crisis rocking the Fountain of Life Church has brought renewed attention to a critical issue many founders of churches, ministries and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) overlook when registering their organisations with the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC): governance and succession planning.

A common misconception among founders is that establishing a church, registering it with the CAC, appointing trustees and investing millions of naira in buildings automatically gives them permanent personal ownership and control of the organisation.

That assumption is wrong.

Under the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) 2020, churches, religious organisations and certain NGOs can be registered as incorporated trustees under Part F of the Act.

Registration under this arrangement does more than provide an organisation with a name and access to a corporate bank account. It establishes a legal entity distinct from the individuals who founded or manage it.

For instance, when Pastor A establishes Grace Assembly and registers it with the CAC, the incorporated trustees become a body corporate under Section 830 of CAMA. The organisation can own property, sue and be sued, and continue to exist even after its founder dies.

This legal principle is known as perpetual succession.

But what does this mean for founders, trustees and church leaders?

Founder does not automatically own church property

Imagine establishing a church, registering it with the CAC and building an auditorium worth ₦500 million.

Does that automatically make the property your personal asset?

No.

Section 830 recognises the incorporated trustees as a separate legal entity, while Section 838 provides that the income and property of the association must be applied towards promoting its stated objectives.

In practical terms, church property registered in the name of the incorporated body does not automatically become the personal property of the founder, pastor or trustees.

Founding an organisation does not, by itself, confer perpetual personal ownership over its assets.

Who are the trustees?

Under Section 823 of CAMA, an association seeking incorporation appoints two or more trustees.

These individuals perform important legal and administrative responsibilities on behalf of the organisation. However, their appointment does not automatically make them personal owners of its property.

Trustees are expected to act within the law and the provisions of the organisation’s registered constitution. They cannot simply treat the organisation’s assets as personal possessions or family inheritance.

ALSO READ:  Governor Buni gives Support to Ngurokayayya, Malom challuri/Bulama Amsameri and Jororo Communities of Geidam LGA

Another important distinction is that the Chairman of the Board of Trustees is not automatically the Senior Pastor, just as the Senior Pastor is not automatically the Chairman of the Board of Trustees.

They are separate offices, and the organisation’s constitution should clearly define their respective responsibilities.

Can a founder’s child automatically become the next General Overseer?

The answer is no.

The fact that a man established a church does not automatically confer the right of succession on his biological children after his death.

A church does not become a family inheritance simply because the founder has children.

Succession depends on the church’s constitution and the leadership arrangements established under it.

If the constitution empowers the founder to nominate a successor, that provision must be considered. If the Board of Trustees has the authority to appoint the next Senior Pastor, the prescribed procedure must be followed.

Similarly, where the constitution provides for an election or approval by a governing council, that process must be respected.

Biological relationship alone does not establish a legal entitlement to become the next Senior Pastor.

Can trustees remove a Senior Pastor?

This is one of the issues that can trigger serious leadership disputes within religious organisations.

Some trustees may assume that their position gives them unrestricted authority to remove a Senior Pastor whenever they wish.

That is not necessarily the case.

Sections 836 and 837 of CAMA provide for aspects of the governance and powers of incorporated associations. However, the specific authority to appoint or remove a Senior Pastor must be determined by examining the organisation’s constitution and applicable governance arrangements.

Where the constitution gives that responsibility to the Board of Trustees, the board must exercise it in accordance with the prescribed procedure.

Where the authority belongs to another governing organ, trustees cannot simply assume that responsibility.

Being a trustee does not confer unlimited control over every aspect of a church’s administration and spiritual leadership.

Why every church founder must take the constitution seriously

This is where many founders make a costly mistake.

They rush to the CAC, register their churches, collect their certificates and open corporate bank accounts without paying sufficient attention to the constitution governing the organisation.

Section 827 of CAMA sets out important constitutional requirements for incorporated associations.

ALSO READ:  Man found dead alongside his girlfriend in Delta Sate , Left 'suicide note' on Facebook, said he was battling with depression

These include provisions relating to the organisation’s aims and objectives, appointment and responsibilities of trustees, tenure and replacement of trustees, governing powers, decision-making procedures, meetings and financial management.

A properly drafted constitution should provide clear answers to critical questions:

– Who appoints the next Senior Pastor?
– Who has the authority to remove the Senior Pastor?
– Who controls the church’s administrative affairs?
– Who approves the sale or transfer of church property?
– How are trustees appointed or removed?
– What happens when the founder dies?
– What happens when trustees disagree?

These are not questions that should be left unanswered until a leadership crisis erupts.

The constitution is not merely a document required to complete CAC registration. It is a governance instrument that can determine the direction and future of the organisation.

Can a church change its constitution during a leadership dispute?

Not arbitrarily.

Section 833 of CAMA provides for the alteration of an incorporated association’s constitution through the prescribed resolution and approval process. Section 835 also addresses the validity of alterations made contrary to the applicable statutory requirements.

Consequently, a few individuals cannot simply gather, alter the constitution and assume that the changes are automatically legally effective.

The relevant statutory requirements and the organisation’s own constitutional procedures must be followed.

Any amendment made outside those requirements may be legally ineffective.

Must the founder become Chairman of the Board of Trustees?

No.

CAMA does not make it compulsory for a church founder to serve as Chairman of the Board of Trustees.

The organisation’s constitution should establish how the chairman is appointed and define the responsibilities attached to the office.

Founders should also consider establishing effective checks and balances.

Spiritual leadership, trusteeship, financial management, property administration and general governance should not necessarily be concentrated in one person’s hands without appropriate accountability structures.

A church needs a governance framework capable of surviving beyond the lifetime of its founder.

Fountain of Life Church crisis: the legal questions that matter

The ongoing controversy involving Pastor Jimmy Odukoya and the Board of Trustees of the Fountain of Life Church raises important questions about the relationship between spiritual leadership, corporate governance and succession.

Among the issues requiring examination are:

– Who has the authority to appoint the Senior Pastor under the church’s registered constitution?
– Did the late founder have the power to nominate a successor, and what procedure was required?
– Was Pastor Jimmy Odukoya’s appointment in 2023 made in accordance with the church’s governing rules?
– What powers does the Board of Trustees possess under the registered constitution?
– Were the relevant procedures followed in decisions concerning the church’s leadership?

ALSO READ:  New Yam Festival: Oba of Benin Leads Edo People in Prayer and Fasting

These questions cannot be conclusively answered by relying on public statements or personal claims alone.

The actual registered constitution, relevant resolutions and other supporting documents must be examined.

It is not enough for someone to argue, “The founder said this.”

It is not enough for another person to insist, “We are the trustees.”

Neither is it sufficient to say, “I am the founder’s son.”

The legal authority of each person must be established by reference to the applicable law and the church’s governing documents.

Founders must plan beyond CAC registration

My advice to anyone planning to establish a church, ministry, foundation or NGO is straightforward: do not just register your organisation; plan its governance.

Do not wait until the founder dies before discussing succession.

Do not wait until trustees begin fighting before examining the constitution.

Do not wait until someone attempts to sell church property before defining the limits of their authority.

The time to establish these structures is when the organisation is being formed, not when a dispute has already reached the courtroom.

A founder may establish an organisation, build its reputation and invest enormous resources in its growth. But without a properly designed governance structure, the founder may discover that personal expectations do not necessarily translate into legal rights.

Trustees must understand that trusteeship is a responsibility, not an opportunity to take over an organisation. Pastors must also recognise that spiritual authority and corporate authority are not necessarily the same thing.

Ultimately, the constitution hurriedly submitted to the CAC today may become the most important document in court tomorrow.

 


Share This Now!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *